① join_chat never emitted
Connection succeeds and the server joins the socket to user_N. But
chat_message is broadcast to chat_N. If the client/provider
never emits join_chat {chat_id} that socket is not in the chat room
and every message is silently dropped.
✅ Emit join_chat immediately after connect fires.
② Redis publish/subscribe channel mismatch
Laravel publishes to nokhba-chat using predis on
127.0.0.1:6379. Node subscribes to the same channel via npm redis.
If the server's production.js Redis config points to a different host, port,
password, or DB index than Laravel's .env they talk to separate Redis instances
and messages never cross.
✅ Make sure both use identical host + port + password + DB number.
③ Laravel predis uses a different DB index
Node's createClient() defaults to DB 0. Laravel's
config/database.php may route the default Redis connection to
DB 1+ for cache separation. Check REDIS_DB in your .env.
Also: REDIS_PASSWORD=null in .env is a literal string
"null" — predis treats it as a real password. Change it to an empty value
(REDIS_PASSWORD=) if Redis has no auth.